Get my cash offer
Blue siding house with white trim

Sell a Rental Property in Indiana, Tenants and All

Maybe the rental has been a headache for years, the tenants stopped paying, or you're ready to stop taking repair calls in January. You can sell a rental with tenants in place, after they move out, or as-is. Here's what to think about.

Selling with tenants in place

In Indiana, an existing lease generally stays in effect when a rental is sold, and the new owner steps in as landlord, including responsibility for the tenant's security deposit. Tenants are also entitled to reasonable notice before anyone enters. Indiana's landlord-tenant laws set most of the rules, and a landlord-tenant attorney can answer questions about your lease.

If a tenant has stopped paying, follow the court eviction process. Never change locks, shut off utilities or remove belongings yourself.

Your options

Keep it and hire a manager

A property manager handles tenants and repairs for a fee. Works if the numbers still make sense.

Wait for the lease to end, then list

A vacant, cleaned-up home usually shows best and can bring the most from an owner-occupant buyer.

Sell to another investor

Investor buyers expect tenants and may buy with the lease in place.

Sell it as-is for cash

We can buy with tenants in place or after move-out, with the wear and repairs it has now.

Is a cash sale a good fit?

It can help when…

  • The tenant has a lease you don't want to break
  • The house needs turnover repairs you don't want to pay for
  • You live out of town and are done managing from afar

It may not be the best fit when…

  • The home is vacant, updated and in a strong neighborhood. Listing may bring more
  • The rental still makes money and you just need better management
Where we buy

Tired landlord / problem tenants: city guides

Local court and office information for the largest Indiana markets.

Everywhere else we buy

All Indiana locations →

FAQ

Common questions

Can you buy my rental with tenants still living there?

Yes. Your tenants can stay; we take over the lease. The lease generally transfers with the sale, along with the security deposit.

Do I have to finish an eviction before selling?

Not always, but the eviction has to be handled legally either way. Talk to a landlord-tenant attorney about timing.

How do showings work with a tenant there?

We usually need just one walkthrough, scheduled with proper notice to the tenant.

Ready to see your offer?

Enter your address. It takes a few minutes and there's no obligation.