Sell a Rental Property in Indiana, Tenants and All
Maybe the rental has been a headache for years, the tenants stopped paying, or you're ready to stop taking repair calls in January. You can sell a rental with tenants in place, after they move out, or as-is. Here's what to think about.
Selling with tenants in place
In Indiana, an existing lease generally stays in effect when a rental is sold, and the new owner steps in as landlord, including responsibility for the tenant's security deposit. Tenants are also entitled to reasonable notice before anyone enters. Indiana's landlord-tenant laws set most of the rules, and a landlord-tenant attorney can answer questions about your lease.
If a tenant has stopped paying, follow the court eviction process. Never change locks, shut off utilities or remove belongings yourself.
Your options
Keep it and hire a manager
A property manager handles tenants and repairs for a fee. Works if the numbers still make sense.
Wait for the lease to end, then list
A vacant, cleaned-up home usually shows best and can bring the most from an owner-occupant buyer.
Sell to another investor
Investor buyers expect tenants and may buy with the lease in place.
Sell it as-is for cash
We can buy with tenants in place or after move-out, with the wear and repairs it has now.
Is a cash sale a good fit?
It can help when…
- The tenant has a lease you don't want to break
- The house needs turnover repairs you don't want to pay for
- You live out of town and are done managing from afar
It may not be the best fit when…
- The home is vacant, updated and in a strong neighborhood. Listing may bring more
- The rental still makes money and you just need better management
Tired landlord / problem tenants: city guides
Local court and office information for the largest Indiana markets.
Everywhere else we buy
Common questions
Can you buy my rental with tenants still living there?
Yes. Your tenants can stay; we take over the lease. The lease generally transfers with the sale, along with the security deposit.
Do I have to finish an eviction before selling?
Not always, but the eviction has to be handled legally either way. Talk to a landlord-tenant attorney about timing.
How do showings work with a tenant there?
We usually need just one walkthrough, scheduled with proper notice to the tenant.
Other situations we help with
Ready to see your offer?
Enter your address. It takes a few minutes and there's no obligation.