Get my cash offer
Central Union Bank building, Evansville

Sell Your Evansville Rental Property, Tenants and All

Maybe the Evansville rental has been a steady earner and you're simply ready to retire from landlording. Maybe the 2 a.m. calls about the water heater have worn thin. Either way, you can sell the Evansville property with tenants in place, and we'll take over the lease.

Get my cash offer

Central Union Bank building, Evansville.
First steps

Selling with tenants in place

In Indiana, an existing lease generally stays in effect when a Evansville rental is sold, and the buyer steps in as landlord, including responsibility for the tenant's security deposit. When we buy in Vanderburgh County, your tenants can stay and we take over the lease.

Why landlords sell

Landlording math changes over time. Rents may have risen, but so have insurance, taxes and the price of a new roof. If the Evansville property no longer pays you enough for the hassle, it may be time to cash out.

Local picture

Rentals around Evansville

Evansville by the numbers: 117,298 people in 2020, part of Vanderburgh County. It is the Vanderburgh County seat. Areas we cover include the West Side, the East Side and the North Side; the closest cities on our list are Bloomington and Terre Haute.

Evansville sits on a bend of the Ohio River, and older neighborhoods such as Haynie's Corner, the Riverside historic district and Jacobsville hold many homes built before World War II. Newer subdivisions spread east and north toward the edges of Vanderburgh County.

Whether your Evansville rental sits near the North Side or elsewhere in Vanderburgh County, the approach is the same: we look at the lease, the rent, the condition and recent sales, then make an offer that works with the tenant staying put.

River cities have their own housing quirks. In Evansville, older homes near the riverfront and downtown often come with basements, original systems and, in some spots, mapped floodplain worth checking on FEMA's maps.

Selling a rental in another part of Vanderburgh County, like Darmstadt? Same process. We buy in Warrick County and Posey County too.

Talk to an Indiana landlord-tenant attorney

We're not attorneys. An Indiana landlord-tenant lawyer can review the Evansville lease and tell you what transfers to a buyer.

How we buy rentals

We pay with our own money and close ourselves through a licensed Indiana title company, typically within 30 days. Rents and deposits on the Evansville property are handled at closing as the purchase agreement spells out, so the handoff is clean.

When to keep or list instead

If the Evansville rental is vacant, updated and in a sought-after area, listing it to owner-occupant buyers may bring more. We'll tell you if that looks like the case.

Straight answers

Evansville landlord questions

Do you buy rentals across Vanderburgh County?

Yes. We buy single-family rentals, 2 to 4 unit buildings and apartment properties with 5 or more units in Evansville and the rest of Vanderburgh County, with tenants in place or vacant.

Can you buy my Evansville rental with tenants living there?

Yes. Your tenants can stay, and we take over the lease. The lease and deposit generally transfer with the sale.

Will you buy several of my Evansville rentals together?

We can look at them together or one at a time. Each gets its own offer and explanation.

Will the lease terms change when you take over?

We take over the existing lease as written. Anything after it ends follows the lease and Indiana law.

Get your Evansville cash offer

Enter your address. It takes a few minutes and there's no obligation.