Get my cash offer
Buskirk-Chumley Theater, Bloomington

We Buy Rental Houses in Bloomington

If you'd rather spend your weekends on anything other than showing a vacant unit, read on. We buy Bloomington rentals directly, with tenants in place or empty, and you skip the make-ready.

Get my cash offer

Buskirk-Chumley Theater, Bloomington. Photo: Geoffrey McKim / CC BY-SA 2.0
First steps

Selling with tenants in place

In Indiana, an existing lease generally stays in effect when a Bloomington rental is sold, and the buyer steps in as landlord, including responsibility for the tenant's security deposit. When we buy in Monroe County, your tenants can stay and we take over the lease.

Why landlords sell

Turnover is where rental profits go to hide. Paint, carpet, cleaning and a month or two of vacancy add up fast. Selling with the tenant in place lets you skip the make-ready on the Bloomington unit entirely.

Local picture

Rentals around Bloomington

Population 79,168 as of the 2020 census, Bloomington spans neighborhoods like neighborhoods near campus, the east side and Prospect Hill. It is the Monroe County seat. The next-closest cities we cover are Indianapolis and Terre Haute.

Wooded lots, slopes and limestone foundations are part of Bloomington's charm, and they're also what inspectors look at closely: drainage, retaining walls, basements and tree damage come up often in Monroe County homes.

Landlords in Monroe County often own more than one door. If you have a small portfolio in and around Bloomington, near the east side or farther out, ask about them together; we'll look at each property on its own terms.

As the Monroe County seat and a college town, Bloomington has longtime owners alongside student and faculty renters. Older homes near downtown carry the upkeep that comes with age.

Selling a rental elsewhere in Monroe County? We buy in places like Stinesville and Ellettsville, and in neighboring Morgan County and Lawrence County.

Talk to an Indiana landlord-tenant attorney

We're not attorneys. An Indiana landlord-tenant lawyer can review the Bloomington lease and tell you what transfers to a buyer.

How we buy rentals

Small multi-family owners are welcome. We buy duplexes, triplexes and fourplexes, and apartment buildings with five or more units. Bring the rent roll and we'll look at the whole picture.

When to keep or list instead

Waiting for the lease to end and then listing can make sense if you have time and can fund the make-ready. Run both scenarios through our net proceeds calculator.

Straight answers

Bloomington landlord questions

Can my Bloomington tenants stay after you buy?

Yes. Tenants can stay; we take over the lease and the security deposit that goes with it. We'll coordinate the walkthrough with proper notice.

What happens to the security deposit?

It transfers with the property at closing, along with responsibility for returning it under the lease.

Do I need to fix up the unit first?

No. We buy as-is, and you can leave old appliances, materials and anything else behind.

Do you charge any fees?

No commission. Closing costs are split the customary way and shown on your written offer.

Get your Bloomington cash offer

Enter your address. It takes a few minutes and there's no obligation.