Get my cash offer
A white house on a lake surrounded by trees

Cash Offer vs. Listing: Do the Net Proceeds Math

The offer price isn't what you walk away with. To compare a cash offer with listing, look at net proceeds: what's left after repairs, commissions, closing costs and the months you keep paying for the house. Here's a worked example and a calculator you can fill in with your own numbers.

Why net proceeds matter

A listing price is usually higher than a cash offer. But listing often comes with repair and prep costs, agent commissions, seller closing costs and months of mortgage, taxes, insurance and utilities while the home is on the market. A cash sale usually has fewer of those costs, but a lower price.

Sometimes listing still nets clearly more. Sometimes the gap is smaller than it looks. The only way to know is to run the numbers for your home.

A worked example (example numbers only)

Every number below is a made-up example to show the math. It is not a quote, an estimate of your home's value or a statement of what anyone charges.

Example net proceeds
Example onlyListingCash offer
Sale price (example)$200,000$160,000
Repairs and prep before selling (example)-$12,000$0
Agent commissions (example: 5%; negotiable)-$10,000$0
Seller closing costs (example)-$3,000$0
Holding costs: 4 vs. 1 month(s) at $1,200/mo (example)-$4,800-$1,200
Net before mortgage payoff$170,200$158,800

Price gap: $40,000. Net gap: $11,400. Your mortgage payoff comes out of either number the same way.

In this example, listing nets more, but the difference is much smaller than the price gap, and the cash sale has no repairs, showings or risk of a buyer's loan falling through. With different numbers (a home that needs more work, a slower market, or higher monthly costs) the result can flip.

Run your own numbers

Start with your own estimates. The example numbers are placeholders, not a quote.

Listing with an agent

Cash offer

Both

Listing net-
Cash net-
Difference-

Net before your mortgage payoff. For estimates only. Not an offer, an appraisal or financial advice.

Questions to ask before you decide

  • What would a local agent list the home for, as-is and after repairs?
  • What would the repairs really cost? Get bids, not guesses.
  • How long do similar homes nearby take to sell right now?
  • What does the house cost you each month you own it?
  • Who pays closing costs in the cash offer? Get it in writing.

General information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Last updated 2026-10-31.

FAQ

Quick answers

Is a cash offer always lower?

The offer price usually is. Your net proceeds may or may not be, depending on repairs, commissions, closing costs and how long the home would take to sell.

Are agent commissions fixed?

No. Commissions are negotiable, and how buyer-agent compensation is handled can vary. Ask any agent you interview to explain their fees in writing.