Get my cash offer
Lake Michigan view from Miller Beach, Gary

Sell a Gary House With Delinquent Property Taxes

Indiana counties hold a tax sale each year for properties with delinquent taxes. If your Gary home is on that path, knowing the steps helps you choose between paying, redeeming or selling.

Lake Michigan view from Miller Beach, Gary.
Straight answers

Back taxes in Gary: questions

Who do I call about back taxes on my Gary house?

Start with the Lake County Treasurer's Office. They can tell you what's owed and whether the parcel is on the tax sale list. The county auditor's office is also involved in tax sales.

Do you charge anything up front?

No. You should never pay anyone up front to sell your house or to deal with a tax sale.

What if I inherited the house with taxes owed?

Whoever has authority over the estate or the property will need to handle it. A probate attorney can help.

Can I set up a payment plan for back taxes?

Ask the treasurer. Options vary, and the office can explain what's available to you.

Property taxes in Lake County

In Lake County, Gary is home to 69,093 people (2020 census). The Lake County seat is Crown Point. We buy near Midtown, in Emerson, around Aetna and beyond, and also in Hammond and South Bend.

Gary, on Lake Michigan in Lake County, has a large stock of older homes in neighborhoods like Miller Beach, Glen Park, Midtown and Emerson, along with vacant and inherited properties that often need significant work.

In Lake County, the county treasurer collects property taxes, including on homes in Gary. If you've fallen behind, call or visit the Lake County Treasurer's Office. They can give you the amount and the deadlines that apply.

With older, vacant or inherited houses in Gary, title and tax questions can come up, so we work closely with the title company before setting a closing date. Neighborhoods range from Miller Beach to Glen Park and Aetna.

Not in Gary itself? Selling a house with back taxes anywhere in Lake County works the same way, including Whiting, New Chicago and Schneider, plus Newton County and Porter County.

How Indiana tax sales work

Under Indiana law, a Gary property can become eligible for the Lake County tax sale when the prior year's spring installment is still unpaid, according to Nolo's summary of the statute. Gary owners are sent notices before the sale, and the county must get a court judgment first.

What to do first

Check whether you're receiving the deductions you qualify for, such as the homestead deduction. The county auditor's office can explain what's available.

When selling helps

A free cash offer gives you a number to weigh against paying the taxes and keeping the Gary house. There's no obligation, and you can still choose to keep it.

When paying and keeping is better

If the amount owed is small compared with the home's value, paying it and listing later may net more than a quick sale. We'll be honest about that.

Get your Gary cash offer

Enter your address. It takes a few minutes and there's no obligation.